The story, first published in 1900 by the and later expanded by the Masonic Order and Ye Mystic Krewe of Gasparilla , claims:
While Tampa, Florida, is not historically documented as a permanent base for Golden Age pirates (circa 1650–1730), the region’s geography, Native American trade networks, and strategic location in the Gulf of Mexico made it a significant hiding ground, watering stop, and raiding target. The modern identity of “Tampa pirate history” is overwhelmingly defined by the legendary (and fictional) pirate (“Gasparilla”), whose myth has evolved into the city’s dominant cultural event: the Gasparilla Pirate Festival . This report separates documented historical facts from folklore, detailing real pirate activity in Tampa Bay and the creation of the Gasparilla legend.
Inspired by the spectacle of New Orleans’ Mardi Gras, Hardee suggested a pirate theme based on local myths he had heard while working near Charlotte Harbor.
Overall, Tampa's pirate history is a rich and fascinating part of the city's heritage, with many stories of swashbuckling adventure and hidden treasure waiting to be uncovered.
One pirate who did leave a lasting impact on Tampa was Charles Vane, an English pirate who operated in the Caribbean and the Gulf during the early 18th century. In 1718, Vane and his crew blockaded the port of Pensacola, which led to a significant shift in the pirate's operations. Some historians believe that Vane may have used Tampa Bay as a temporary base, taking advantage of its seclusion and access to the Gulf.